For several nights in September 1903, something strange was reportedly happening in the small coal-mining community of Van Meter, Iowa. Residents began describing an unusual figure appearing after dark, moving through the town and eventually disappearing in the direction of an abandoned coal mine. What started as a peculiar sighting soon developed into one of the strangest and most enduring cryptid stories in the American Midwest.
The creature would eventually become known as the Van Meter Visitor. Accounts described it as large and winged, with an appearance unlike anything witnesses recognized. Perhaps the strangest detail involved what appeared to be a horn or projection on its forehead. According to reports, witnesses believed a powerful beam of light came from this area, illuminating the darkness as the creature moved around town.
What makes the Van Meter story particularly interesting is that reports appeared in newspapers at the time rather than emerging entirely as folklore decades later. Several people identified in those accounts were established members of the community, including businessmen and a physician. However, the existence of contemporary reporting does not mean the extraordinary details were necessarily accurate. Newspapers of that era frequently published sensational stories, and separating observation from exaggeration more than a century later is difficult.
One of the earliest witnesses associated with the story was local businessman U.G. Griffith. During the early morning hours, Griffith reportedly noticed a strange light moving around town. At first, there was little reason to believe anything supernatural or unknown was responsible, but the reports quickly became more elaborate.
The following night, Peter Dunn, who was associated with the local bank, reportedly encountered something outside the building. According to accounts of the incident, Dunn heard an unusual sound and went to investigate. There he supposedly saw the mysterious creature.
Dunn reportedly drew his revolver and fired several times. Despite the gunfire, the creature apparently escaped without any obvious injury. Afterward, Dunn discovered what he believed was an unusual footprint and reportedly made a plaster cast of it. The track was described as having three toes.
Unfortunately, the alleged cast does not provide modern investigators with verifiable physical evidence. There is no specimen available today that could conclusively demonstrate that an unknown animal walked through Van Meter that night.
The encounters nevertheless continued.
Another prominent resident, Dr. Alcott, reportedly saw the creature during the strange series of events. According to later retellings of the contemporary reports, Alcott initially suspected someone might be playing a prank. When he approached the mysterious figure, however, it supposedly revealed enormous wings and flew away.
By this point, Van Meter had a mystery on its hands.
Descriptions circulating around town portrayed something roughly human-sized or larger, capable of flight and accompanied by an unpleasant odor. The brilliant light associated with its forehead became one of the most distinctive elements of the story. Witnesses also claimed the creature seemed remarkably resistant to attempts to frighten or injure it.
Then residents reportedly began noticing a pattern. The creature appeared to be travelling toward an old abandoned coal mine outside Van Meter. A group of armed townspeople eventually gathered near the mine, apparently hoping to discover what had been frightening residents. According to the story that developed from the contemporary reports, they weren’t confronted by just one mysterious creature. There appeared to be two.
The creatures reportedly emerged near the mine while the men were waiting. Gunfire followed, but once again, witnesses claimed the bullets seemed to have little effect. The strange winged figures eventually retreated toward the mine and disappeared.
The following morning, townspeople reportedly returned to the area. According to the traditional account, the entrance to the mine was sealed.
Then something remarkable happened. The sightings stopped. There were no more nightly appearances of the strange glowing creature terrorizing Van Meter. Whatever had been responsible for the extraordinary few days seemed to disappear almost as suddenly as it had arrived.
More than a century later, however, there is no convincing physical evidence demonstrating that an unknown winged species actually inhabited the abandoned mine. No body was recovered. No bones belonging to an unidentified giant flying animal were produced. There are no verified photographs of the creature, and the alleged footprint cast has not provided the kind of evidence necessary to establish that something scientifically unknown was present.
That leaves plenty of room for more ordinary explanations.
Large birds are one possibility. In darkness, especially when people are frightened or observing something only briefly, familiar animals can appear dramatically different from what they really are. Owls and other large birds can produce unsettling sounds, possess impressive wingspans and appear surprisingly human-like under certain conditions. Once stories about a mysterious creature began circulating around Van Meter, later witnesses may also have interpreted ambiguous sights and sounds through the lens of what they had already heard.
The mysterious light is harder to reconcile with an ordinary animal if the reports are taken literally. An unknown terrestrial creature capable of projecting a powerful beam from its forehead would represent something extraordinary, and there is no known biological mechanism that closely resembles the descriptions attributed to the Visitor. That raises the possibility that the light and the creature were separate phenomena that became connected during retellings—or that the detail was exaggerated as the story spread.
Another possibility is that at least part of the episode was a prank or hoax. Small communities were hardly immune to practical jokes, and newspapers of the early twentieth century had an appetite for bizarre stories. Once several respected residents became associated with the sightings, however, the story gained credibility locally and became increasingly difficult to untangle.
There is also the possibility that the witnesses genuinely encountered something they couldn’t identify. That doesn’t necessarily mean it was an undiscovered monster. A strange animal, unusual bird, atmospheric phenomenon or combination of unrelated events could have provided the foundation from which the larger legend grew.
And grow it certainly did.
Over time, the Van Meter Visitor became increasingly elaborate in popular retellings. Modern illustrations often depict a terrifying gargoyle-like creature with enormous leathery wings and a glowing horn protruding from its forehead. Those images are artistic interpretations, however, and shouldn’t be mistaken for photographs or exact representations of what the original witnesses saw.
That distinction is important because the real mystery isn’t whether a modern drawing accurately depicts the Visitor. It is what caused several residents of Van Meter to become convinced that something extraordinary was moving through their town during those nights in September 1903.
Maybe an unusually large bird repeatedly visited the area.
Maybe someone orchestrated an elaborate prank.
Maybe sensational newspaper reporting transformed a handful of strange encounters into a monster story.
Or perhaps the people of Van Meter really did see something they couldn’t explain.
Whatever happened, the story has survived for more than 120 years. For a brief period in September 1903, people in a quiet Iowa town reportedly watched strange lights move through the darkness, heard unsettling noises and described a large winged creature that seemed to disappear into an abandoned mine.
Then the mine was sealed, the Visitor vanished, and Van Meter returned to normal.
But the question never completely disappeared with it:
What were the people of Van Meter seeing in the darkness?
Sources: contemporary and subsequently archived Iowa newspaper coverage of the September 1903 Van Meter reports, the Van Meter Visitor Festival and local historical material, the book The Van Meter Visitor by Chad Lewis, Noah Voss and Kevin Lee Nelson, and later historical and folkloric examinations of the Van Meter legend.
A little magic is always waiting. Subscribe and step inside the circle. 🖤🔮✨
The Cool Beans 
Leave a comment