Jessie didn’t sleep.
At three seventeen in the morning, she stopped pretending she was going to.
She sat at her kitchen table with Daniel’s cassette player in front of her, the brass key beside it and a glass of water she had poured two hours earlier and forgotten to drink. The apartment was silent except for the refrigerator humming and the occasional sound of a car passing outside.
Gabriel had taken the couch. Anna had claimed the armchair. Both had argued that Jessie shouldn’t be alone, and Jessie had been too tired to object convincingly.
She played the cassette again. Not all of it, just one part.
He didn’t find me. He was looking for me.
Jessie stopped the tape. Her mother. Catherine Wilson.
Until tonight, Jessie’s memories of Catherine had been fragments without context. Cigarette smoke drifting through a kitchen window. A red wool coat. Her mother’s fingers working knots from Jessie’s hair. Tomato soup when Jessie was sick. A voice singing badly while washing dishes.
Then Catherine had died when Jessie was fourteen. At least that was what Jessie remembered, and now her mother had a second life inside Jessie’s first. Catherine Wilson had created something meant to help people disappear from danger. Daniel had rebuilt it, Vale had corrupted it, Rachel had apparently returned to it and Jessie had forgotten all of them.
She heard movement behind her. Gabriel appeared in the kitchen doorway looking as though the couch had personally offended him.
“You’re awake.”
“So are you.”
“Your couch is terrible.”
“You’re welcome.”
He opened a cupboard. “Coffee?”
“It’s three in the morning.”
“You haven’t slept.”
“Neither have you.”
“Exactly.”
Jessie considered arguing, then pointed to another cupboard. “Filters.”
Gabriel began making coffee and for several minutes neither spoke.
Finally he said, “Are you scared?”
Jessie looked at him.
“Of Rachel?”
“Of tomorrow.”
She thought about it.
“Yes.”
Gabriel nodded.
“You’re not going to tell me I shouldn’t be?”
“No.”
“Good.”
“I’m learning.”
“Slowly.”
He poured water into the machine. “You haven’t seen your sister in twenty-four years.”
“I haven’t remembered having a sister in twenty-four years.”
“That seems worse.”
“It is.”
Gabriel turned toward her. “What do you think she’ll say?”
Jessie looked at the brass key.
“I don’t know.”
“What do you want her to say?”
That question was harder.
Jessie wanted Rachel to run toward her.
She wanted forgiveness before she’d earned it. She wanted Sophie to call her Aunt Jessie again and somehow erase the twenty-four years between those two moments. She wanted her mother to turn out to have been good, Daniel to have been right about everything and every terrible choice Jessie had made to be revealed as necessary.
She wanted the past to rearrange itself into something easier to live with.
Instead she said, “I want her to tell me the truth.”
Gabriel watched her.
“Even if she hates you?”
“Especially then.”
At eight thirty they left.
The detective knew where they were going. Jessie had insisted on that herself. Officers would remain far enough away not to turn the reunion into a raid but close enough to respond if something went wrong.
Michael met them at a gas station thirty kilometres from the property. Jessie recognized him immediately from the photograph Sophie had sent. He was taller than Daniel had been, though age had bent him slightly through the shoulders. Dark hair had gone mostly grey at the temples. His face was lean and harder than Daniel’s, but there was something in the eyes that made Jessie uncomfortable.
Not resemblance, history. He got out of his car and looked at her. Neither moved.
“So,” Jessie said, “you’re Michael.”
“So you’re Jessie.”
“I’ve been told.”
Gabriel muttered something.
Michael looked at him.
“You shot my brother.”
Gabriel sighed. “We’re doing this immediately?”
“You did.”
“Yes.”
Jessie stepped between them. “Michael stabbed him.”
Gabriel looked at her. Michael looked at her.
Jessie shrugged. “I thought I’d establish the general level of moral superiority before we start.”
Anna laughed from the passenger seat. Michael almost smiled.
Good.
People who could still laugh were easier to read. Rebecca climbed out of Michael’s car and Gabriel’s composure vanished. He crossed the distance between them quickly, and for one awful second Jessie wondered whether Rebecca would pull away, but she didn’t. Gabriel wrapped his arms around his daughter and Rebecca held him tightly.
Jessie looked away. Some reunions belonged to the people inside them. When she finally looked back, Rebecca was wiping her eyes.
She was thirty-two, with dark hair pulled loosely behind her head and an expression that reminded Jessie immediately of the little girl in the clinic.
Watchful, not frightened. She was observant.
Rebecca looked at Jessie. “You really don’t remember me.”
It wasn’t an accusation. Jessie shook her head. “Pieces.”
Rebecca nodded. “That’s more than yesterday.”
“I remember the blue pencil.”
Rebecca’s expression changed. “You do?”
“You gave it to me.” A small smile appeared.
“I liked the red one better.” Jessie laughed softly.
“I remember thinking you were strange.”
“I was eight.”
“You were strange.”
Rebecca smiled properly then.
Gabriel looked between them.
“This is unsettling.”
“Wait until we start discussing your parenting,” Jessie said.
“Absolutely not.”
For the first time since St. Catherine’s, something almost normal moved through the group.
It didn’t last.
Michael looked toward the road.
“We should go.”
The house stood twelve kilometres farther north. The pavement narrowed to gravel, then to a road barely wide enough for two vehicles. Dense forest pressed in from both sides. Autumn had begun turning the trees, streaking the landscape with gold, red and rust beneath a grey morning sky.
Jessie began recognizing things before she remembered them. A bend in the road, a broken stone wall, a narrow bridge over shallow water. Her body knew the route, but her mind did not. Then the trees opened and the house appeared. It was enormous but not elegant. Not anymore.
Three storeys of weathered grey stone and dark timber stood at the edge of a clearing. Ivy covered part of one wall. Several windows had been replaced, others boarded. A wide porch wrapped around the front. It looked less like a criminal headquarters than a place where someone might sell homemade jam.
Danger should have the courtesy to look dangerous.
Jessie saw that Michael had stopped walking.
“You okay?”
“No.”
“Good. Apparently that’s our group motto.”
He didn’t smile.
“I haven’t been here since Daniel took me away.”
“You were eleven.”
“Yes.”
“What do you remember?”
“Everything.”
Jessie understood the cruelty in that immediately. She had spent days furious because she couldn’t remember. Michael had spent decades unable to forget. Neither was freedom. The front door opened and a woman stepped onto the porch.
Jessie stopped breathing. It was Rachel. She was older than the photograph, older than Jessie’s memories. Her hair was mostly grey now, cut just below her shoulders. Her face carried lines Jessie had never seen form. She wore jeans, boots and a dark sweater.
For several seconds the sisters simply looked at each other. Jessie’s mind tried to replace the woman with the nineteen-year-old standing in the kitchen but it couldn’t. Rachel wasn’t a memory, she was here. She was alive.
Jessie took one step forward. Rachel’s expression hardened. That made Jessie stop.
Good.
Choice.
She would let Rachel choose. Sophie appeared behind her and Jessie’s heart broke all over again.
Thirty years old, not six. She had dark hair, Rachel’s crooked smile, serious eyes. Jessie remembered sticky fingers around her waist.
Aunt Jessie.
Sophie stared at her. Nobody spoke. And then Rachel came down the steps and she walked directly to Jessie.
Jessie prepared herself for anything.
A slap. An accusation. Silence.
Rachel stopped inches away. “You got old.”
Jessie stared. “So did you.”
Rachel’s mouth trembled. “You look like Mom.”
Jessie felt tears immediately. “That seems unfair. I barely remember her.”
Rachel’s eyes filled. “I know.”
Then Rachel slapped her, hard. So hard that Jessie’s head turned.
Gabriel moved instinctively, but Jessie raised a hand. “No.”
Rachel was crying now. “That was for telling me to let Sophie hate you.”
Jessie touched her cheek. “Fair.”
Rachel slapped her again. “That was for disappearing.”
“Also fair.”
Rachel lifted her hand a third time and Jessie braced herself for it. Instead Rachel grabbed her and pulled her into an embrace. Jessie froze, then broke. As she held her sister twenty-four years vanished and didn’t vanish at all. Rachel smelled different. Her hair felt different. Her body was smaller than Jessie remembered but the way she held Jessie was the same. One hand at the back of her head. Exactly as she had when Jessie was fourteen and their mother died.
Jessie cried against her sister’s shoulder. “I forgot you.”
Rachel held tighter. I know.”
“I forgot Sophie.”
“I know.”
“I’m sorry.”
Rachel pulled back. “You don’t get to apologize for something someone did to your brain.”
“I agreed to it.”
“To save us.”
“I still forgot.”
Rachel touched Jessie’s face. “But you came back.”
Jessie shook her head. “Twenty-four years late.”
“No.” Rachel looked directly at her. “You came back twice.”
Jessie stared. Rachel glanced toward the house. “That’s the part you don’t remember.”
Sophie remained on the porch. Jessie looked at her, but she didn’t move closer and neither did Sophie.
Finally Jessie said, “Hi.”
Sophie laughed through tears. “Hi.”
Jessie swallowed. “I don’t know what I’m supposed to say.”
“That’s new.” Jessie smiled faintly.
“You remember me being difficult?”
“I remember you teaching me how to pick a lock.”
Gabriel made a noise behind them.
Jessie turned.
“What?”
“She was six.”
“I was apparently an unconventional aunt.”
Sophie smiled. “You told Mom it was an important life skill.”
“It is.”
Rachel rolled her eyes. Some things had survived. Sophie came down the steps and she stopped in front of Jessie. Jessie did not reach for her.
“I remember you,” Sophie said.
Jessie nodded. “I wish I remembered more.”
“I know.”
“You don’t owe me anything.”
Sophie studied her.
“You really have changed.”
“People keep saying that. It’s becoming suspicious.”
Then Sophie hugged her. Jessie closed her eyes.
This time the memory came.
Six-year-old Sophie running toward her.
Small arms.
Laughter.
Aunt Jessie.
Past and present overlapped for one impossible second.
Jessie held her niece. When Sophie stepped away, she wiped her face. “Okay. That’s enough emotional trauma before breakfast.”
Jessie laughed. Definitely family. Rachel looked toward Michael and everything changed. Michael stood beside Rebecca near the vehicles.
Rachel’s face went cold. “You brought him.”
“You asked me to.”
“I asked you to bring Michael. I didn’t say I’d be happy about it.”
Michael approached slowly.
Rachel watched him.
“You look like Eleanor.” Michael stopped.
Jessie saw the impact. “You knew her.”
Rachel nodded. “Better than you did.”
Michael’s face hardened. “That wouldn’t be difficult.”
“Come inside.” The interior of the house was warmer than Jessie expected. Not abandoned, not hidden headquarters but a home.
Bookshelves covered the walls. Old rugs softened wooden floors. Photographs sat on tables. Plants crowded windows. People lived here. Jessie noticed doors with newer locks, reinforced window frames and cameras discreetly positioned outside. A safe place built by people who understood unsafe ones. Rachel led them into a large dining room. A long wooden table filled most of it.
Jessie stopped. There were names carved into the surface. Dozens.
Some she recognized. Anna. Evan. Laura. Michael. Daniel. Catherine. Then Jessie found her own.
JESSIE W.
Below it, smaller: SOPHIE.
“What is this?”
“The people who came through Second Life,” Rachel said.
Jessie stared at the names.
“There are more than Vale’s candidates.”
“Much more.”
“How many?”
“Over the years?”
Rachel looked at the table.
“Hundreds.”
Jessie turned.
“Hundreds?”
“Vale was never the whole story.”
Rachel sat. down and the others followed. Jessie remained standing. Rachel looked at Michael.
“You were told your mother died when you were six.”
“Yes.”
“She didn’t.”
Michael’s jaw tightened. “I know that now.”
“No. You know she survived.”
Rachel’s voice softened. “You don’t know why she left you.”
Michael said nothing. “She didn’t leave you.”
Rachel reached beneath the table and removed a box. “She hid you.”
Michael stared. “From who?”
Rachel looked at Jessie. “Your mother.”
Jessie frowned. “My mother?”
“Catherine.”
Michael stood abruptly. “No.”
Rachel didn’t flinch.
Jessie felt cold. “Explain.”
Rachel opened the box. Inside were photographs, notebooks and several cassette tapes.
“Our mother created Second Life with Eleanor Mercer.”
Jessie stared. “Together?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because both of them had escaped the same place.”
Michael slowly sat. “What place?”
Rachel looked toward the window. “There was an institution outside Montreal. Officially it was a residential treatment centre for troubled adolescents.”
Jessie already hated the sentence. “What was it actually?”
“A privately funded behavioural program.” Rebecca leaned forward.
“What kind of behavioural program?”
“Attachment. Obedience. Memory. Identity.”
Silence.
Vale’s work.
Before Vale.
“When?” Jessie asked.
“Late 1960s into the seventies.”
“Our mother would have been—”
“Fourteen when she arrived.”
Jessie sat down. “And Eleanor?”
“Fifteen.” Michael looked sick.
“They were subjects.”
“Yes.”
“Candidates?”
“They weren’t called candidates then.”
“What were they called?”
Rachel looked at Michael. “Residents.”
The ordinary word made it worse. “Who ran it?”
“No single person. Doctors. Researchers. Private donors. Some legitimate. Some who knew exactly what was happening. Others who probably believed they were funding youth rehabilitation.”
Rebecca asked, “Was Vale there?”
“Later. He was young. A student.”
Jessie felt everything shift again.
Vale hadn’t invented the work.
He had learned it.
“Catherine and Eleanor escaped together,” Rachel continued. “They spent years finding other people who’d been through the program. Some were homeless. Some incarcerated. Some living under false names. Some had no idea what had happened to them because parts of their memories were gone.”
“Second Life,” Jessie said.
Rachel nodded.
“They built a network to help survivors disappear from the people still tracking them.”
“That was the original Second Life.”
“Yes.”
Michael looked at the table.
“Then what happened?”
Rachel’s expression changed.
“Catherine and Eleanor disagreed.”
“About what?”
“Protection.”
Jessie understood before Rachel explained.
“Who gets to decide.”
Rachel nodded.
“Catherine believed survivors should choose what happened next, even if the choice was dangerous. Eleanor believed people who had been conditioned couldn’t always trust their own decisions.”
Michael closed his eyes.
“So Eleanor started choosing for them.”
“Yes.”
“Where they lived?”
“Yes.”
“Who they contacted?”
“Yes.”
“Whether they remembered?”
Rachel hesitated.
“Yes.”
Jessie felt sick.
The rescue system had become another form of control.
“Catherine tried to stop her.”
“What happened?”
“Second Life split.”
Rachel pointed at the table.
“Catherine kept this place.”
“And Eleanor?”
“She took records, money and several people with her.”
“Where?”
“St. Catherine’s.”
Anna inhaled sharply.
Jessie stared.
“St. Catherine’s existed before Daniel.”
“Yes.”
“Before Vale?”
“Yes.”
“Eleanor built the operation there?”
“She helped build what eventually became it.”
Michael stood.
“My mother.”
Rachel looked at him with something close to compassion.
“Yes.”
“And Vale?”
“Eleanor recruited him.”
Michael turned away.
Jessie watched him.
For years he’d believed Vale was the beginning of his suffering.
Now his own mother stood behind Vale.
Not because she was born cruel.
Because someone had first taught her that control could be called protection.
The pattern was older than any of them.
Jessie looked at Rachel.
“What happened to our mother?”
Rachel’s expression changed.
“That’s why you’re here.”
Jessie’s pulse quickened.
“I thought she died when I was fourteen.”
“She did.”
“How?”
“You remember cancer.”
“Yes.”
“She had cancer.”
Jessie waited.
“But?”
“Cancer wasn’t what killed her.”
Jessie’s stomach tightened.
The same lie Gabriel had been told about Laura.
“What killed her?”
Rachel looked toward Michael.
“Eleanor.”
Michael closed his eyes.
Jessie said nothing.
She felt strangely calm.
“Why?”
“Catherine discovered Eleanor was bringing children into the program.”
“Michael.”
“Yes.”
Jessie looked at him.
“Catherine tried to get you out.”
Michael turned.
“What?”
“She found out Eleanor had placed you inside the St. Catherine’s network. She went to get you.”
“I was eleven.”
“Yes.”
“Daniel found me.”
“Because Catherine sent him.”
Michael stared.
“Daniel knew Catherine?”
“Daniel knew all of us.”
Jessie’s heart tightened.
Daniel again.
Always Daniel.
“How?”
“His mother.”
Jessie remembered the tape.
Catherine knew Daniel’s mother.
Rachel continued. “Daniel’s mother was another survivor from the original institution.”
Anna whispered, “My God.”
“Daniel grew up around Second Life. He knew pieces, never everything. When Catherine realized Michael was trapped, she asked Daniel to find him.”
Michael sat down heavily.
“He was seventeen.”
“Yes.”
“He came into that house for me.”
“Yes.”
“I thought he found me accidentally.”
“No.”
Michael stared at the table.
Jessie watched decades of anger rearrange themselves inside him.
“Catherine died three years later,” Rachel said. “Eleanor made it look natural. Catherine was already ill. Nobody questioned it.”
Jessie felt grief arrive for a mother she barely remembered.
Not sharp.
Deep.
Old.
“Did you know?”
“Not then.”
“When did you find out?”
“After you disappeared.”
“Who told you?”
Rachel looked at Sophie and then back at Jessie.
“Daniel.”
Jessie’s pulse jumped.
“After the fire.”
“Yes.”
“During those six months.”
“Yes.”
Jessie leaned back.
Daniel had survived the fire and found Rachel.
He had told her everything.
“Why didn’t he come back to me?”
Rachel’s face softened.
“He did.”
Jessie stared.
“No.”
“He came to you.”
“When?”
“Six months after St. Catherine’s.”
“The photograph.”
“Yes.”
Jessie shook her head.
“I didn’t recognize him.”
“No.”
“What happened?”
Rachel looked at Sophie.
Sophie took over.
“I remember some of it.”
Jessie turned toward her.
“I was six. I didn’t understand.”
“Tell me what you remember.”
Sophie folded her hands.
“You were here.”
“At this house?”
“Yes.”
“You found us.”
“Yes.”
“Daniel too?”
“Yes.”
Jessie’s throat tightened.
“What happened?”
“You and Daniel argued.”
“About what?”
“I don’t know. Mom made me go upstairs.”
Rachel said, “Daniel wanted you to leave with us.”
“And I refused.”
“Yes.”
Of course.
“Why?”
“You said you had to finish something.”
Jessie closed her eyes.
Always one more thing.
“What?”
Rachel looked toward the box.
“Eleanor.”
Michael lifted his head.
Jessie opened her eyes.
“I went after Eleanor.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because you’d discovered she was rebuilding the program.”
Jessie looked at Michael.
“With Vale.”
Rachel nodded.
“And Daniel wanted me to walk away.”
“He wanted you to let the police handle it.”
Jessie almost laughed. “I assume nineteen-year-old me reacted maturely.”
“You told him the police had been paid by the same people funding the program.”
“That sounds annoyingly reasonable.”
“It was.”
“What happened next?”
Rachel took a breath.
“You left.”
“Alone?”
“Yes.”
“Where did I go?”
“St. Catherine’s.”
Jessie frowned.
“The fire had already happened.”
“Not the church.”
Rachel looked at Michael.
“The other St. Catherine’s.”
Silence.
Jessie stared. “What other St. Catherine’s?”
Michael looked confused too. Rachel reached into the box and removed an old photograph. A large institutional building stood behind iron gates.
Across the entrance were the words: ST. CATHERINE’S YOUTH RECOVERY CENTRE
Jessie felt cold.
“The church wasn’t the original St. Catherine’s.”
“No.”
“Vale reused the name.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because he liked reminding survivors that they never really escaped.”
Jessie looked at the photograph.
“Where is this?”
“Quebec.”
“The original institution?”
Rachel nodded.
“The place our mother and Eleanor escaped.”
Jessie stared.
“You’re telling me I went there.”
“Yes.”
“After my memories were erased.”
“Yes.”
“To stop Eleanor.”
“Yes.”
“Did I?”
Rachel looked at her for a long time.
“No.”
Jessie’s stomach dropped.
“What happened?”
“You joined her.”
Nobody moved.
Gabriel said, “No.”
Anna shook her head.
Michael stared at Jessie.
Jessie looked only at Rachel.
“Say that again.”
“You stayed with Eleanor for almost three months.”
“Why?”
“We didn’t know.”
“Did Daniel?”
“No.”
Jessie’s mind raced. She had forgotten Daniel, forgotten Rachel, forgotten Sophie, forgotten her mother. Then she had found them anyway. Then she had gone after Eleanor and somehow she had stayed.
“Did I work for her?”
Rachel nodded.
“What did I do?”
“We don’t know everything.”
“What do you know?”
“You helped rebuild records.”
Jessie’s blood went cold.
“Second Life records?”
“Yes.”
“Candidate records?”
“Eventually.”
Gabriel whispered, “The foundation.”
Rachel nodded.
“That’s when the money changed direction.”
Jessie stared at the table. There was her third mistake. Not merely sending money. Not merely exposing Rachel. She had helped rebuild the system. Maybe knowingly, maybe not.
“How did I leave?”
Rachel’s eyes filled. “Daniel came for you.”
Jessie stopped breathing. “Again?”
“Yes.”
“What happened?”
“He got you out.”
“And then?”
Rachel looked at Sophie and Sophie lowered her eyes. Jessie already knew this was where Daniel’s story ended.
“He brought you here,” Rachel said. “You stayed one night.”
“Did I remember him?”
“No.”
Jessie’s heart broke. “But you trusted him.”
“How do you know?”
“Because you were terrified of everyone except Daniel.”
Jessie closed her eyes.
Memory without memory. The body remembering what the mind couldn’t.
“What happened the next morning?”
“Daniel left.”
“Why?”
“He said Eleanor would keep coming until someone stopped her.”
Jessie opened her eyes.
“He went back.”
“Yes.”
“Alone?”
Rachel nodded.
“Did he kill her?”
“No.”
“Did she kill him?”
“No.”
Jessie frowned.
“Then who?”
Rachel looked at Michael.
Michael went pale.
“No.”
He stood.
“No.”
Jessie turned toward him.
“What?”
Michael backed away from the table.
“I wasn’t there.”
Rachel didn’t speak.
“I wasn’t.”
“Michael,” she said gently.
“I was with Vale.”
“Yes.”
“Vale sent me somewhere else.”
“Where?”
Michael stopped.
His face changed.
Jessie saw memory arrive.
A memory Michael had apparently never understood.
“He sent me to Quebec.”
Rachel nodded.
“No.”
“You were twenty.”
“No.”
“You went to the original St. Catherine’s.”
Michael shook his head.
“I don’t remember Daniel being there.”
“You weren’t supposed to.”
Michael stared at her.
“What did Vale do?”
Rachel opened another envelope.
Inside was a hospital record. Rebecca stood and took it.
She read. “Michael Mercer. Admitted with head trauma, disorientation and memory loss.”
Michael sat.
Jessie understood. It was not just her. Vale had altered Michael’s memory too.
The control. The one who supposedly remembered everything.
Didn’t.
“What happened there?” Jessie asked Rachel.
Rachel’s eyes filled.
“We only know what Daniel left behind.”
She removed a cassette.
Jessie stared.
“Another one.”
“Daniel made it the night before he died.”
Jessie’s heart pounded.
Rachel placed it on the table.
On the label, in Daniel’s handwriting:
IF MICHAEL REMEMBERS, DO NOT LET HIM FACE IT ALONE.
Michael stared at the tape.
For the first time since Jessie met him, he looked frightened.
“I don’t want to hear it.”
Nobody spoke.
Then Jessie said quietly, “Okay.”
Michael looked at her.
She meant it.
“You don’t have to.”
His eyes narrowed.
“You want to know.”
“Desperately.”
“Then why wouldn’t you play it?”
“Because it’s yours.”
Michael stared at her.
Jessie understood something then.
Vale had spent his life treating people’s minds like locked rooms he had the right to enter.
Old Jessie had done something similar. Locks were challenges. Secrets were currency. People were puzzles.
But Michael wasn’t a lock, he was a person.
“If you want to hear it,” Jessie said, “we’ll hear it. If you don’t, we don’t.”
Michael looked down. Minutes passed. Finally he reached for the cassette.
“Play it.”
Rachel brought an old player from a cabinet. Michael inserted the tape himself and pressed play.
Static filled the room and then Daniel’s voice. Older than the recordings Jessie had heard before. It was tired.
“Michael.”
Michael closed his eyes.
“If you’re hearing this, something went wrong.”
Jessie almost laughed through the tension.
Daniel continued.
“I know you’re angry with me.”
Michael whispered, “You have no idea.”
“I know Vale told you I chose Jessie over you.”
Michael’s eyes opened.
“I didn’t.”
Daniel paused.
“I chose both of you.”
Jessie looked away.
“I kept trying to save everyone because I couldn’t accept that sometimes people have to save themselves.”
Jessie felt that sentence deeply.
“I thought if I worked hard enough, planned carefully enough, lied well enough, I could get all of you out without anyone hating me.”
A quiet laugh. “That was arrogant.”
Jessie smiled faintly. “At least he knew.”
Daniel continued. “Eleanor is here.”
Michael’s breathing changed. “She wants you.”
Michael stared at the player.
“Not because you’re her son.”
The room went still. “Because you’re her proof.”
Michael whispered, “No.”
“Vale told you that you were his control. You weren’t.”
Jessie leaned forward.
“You were Eleanor’s.”
Michael covered his mouth.
“She gave you to Vale.”
Silence.
“Everything he did to you was with her permission.”
Michael’s face collapsed. Rebecca moved beside him. He didn’t push her away.
Daniel’s voice softened. “I’m sorry.”
Michael began crying silently.
“I should have told you sooner. I thought knowing would destroy you.”
Jessie closed her eyes. This was protection through secrecy – again.
“I was wrong.”
Daniel paused.
“Your mother is alive.”
Michael looked up sharply.
Jessie stared at Rachel.
Rachel looked equally shocked.
Daniel continued.
“I couldn’t kill her.”
Jessie’s pulse raced.
“I came here intending to.”
Michael whispered, “Where is she?”
“She told me something before I could.”
The tape hissed.
“Catherine Wilson is alive.”
Jessie stopped breathing.
Rachel stood so quickly her chair fell backward.
“No.”
Daniel’s voice continued.
“Jessie, if you’re hearing this too, I’m sorry.”
Jessie’s hands went numb.
“Your mother did not die when you were fourteen.”
Rachel shook her head violently.
“I saw her body.”
Daniel answered a question recorded twenty-three years ago.
“You saw a body.”
Rachel froze.
“Not Catherine.”
Jessie couldn’t breathe.
Daniel continued.
“Eleanor helped Catherine disappear.”
Michael stared at Rachel.
Rachel stared at Jessie.
Nothing made sense.
“They weren’t enemies when Catherine vanished.”
Daniel said.
“They were still working together.”
Jessie felt sick.
“Everything Rachel was told about Catherine’s death was staged.”
Rachel whispered, “No.”
“Catherine went underground because someone had found Second Life.”
Daniel paused.
“Someone above Vale.”
Jessie leaned closer.
“She spent years trying to identify them.”
Static.
Then:
“She did.”
Everyone waited.
Daniel’s next words were barely audible.
“And that’s why none of you are safe.”
Jessie’s pulse pounded.
“The people who funded the original St. Catherine’s never disappeared.”
Rebecca whispered, “The institutional funding.”
Daniel continued.
“They changed names. Foundations. Clinics. Research programs. Charities. Companies.”
Jessie thought of the modern foundation.
The university.
The clinics.
All of it.
“Vale wasn’t the organization.”
Daniel said.
“He was an employee.”
Jessie stared.
For twenty-four years they’d been treating Vale as the architect. He was only a piece.
“Eleanor wasn’t the organization either.”
Michael wiped his face.
“Then who?”
Daniel’s recording answered.
“I don’t know what they call themselves.”
Static crackled.
“But Catherine does.”
Jessie felt hope and terror collide.
“She’s alive.”
Rachel whispered it this time.
Jessie looked at her sister.
“If Daniel was right.”
The cassette continued.
“Catherine told Eleanor she’d contact her when it was safe.”
A pause.
“She left one way to find her.”
Jessie almost laughed.
Of course she did.
Another trail.
Another key.
Another puzzle left for people who might not remember why they were solving it.
Daniel’s voice softened.
“Jessie knows it.”
Jessie stared at the cassette player.
“No, I don’t.”
Daniel continued.
“She just doesn’t know she knows it.”
Gabriel groaned.
Jessie pointed at the player.
“See? This is why I loved him and wanted to strangle him.”
Despite everything, Anna laughed.
Daniel’s voice continued.
“Catherine taught Jessie something when she was little. A rhyme.”
Jessie’s heart stopped.
A memory surfaced.
Her mother’s voice.
Not words yet.
A melody.
Jessie closed her eyes.
Catherine brushing her hair.
Rachel at the kitchen table doing homework.
Rain against the window.
Her mother singing.
Jessie whispered the first line before she consciously remembered it.
“When the river turns to silver…”
Rachel stared at her.
“You remember.”
Jessie continued.
“…follow where the blackbirds fly.”
Rachel joined her.
“When the cedar bends toward morning…”
Jessie’s eyes filled.
“…look beneath the watchful eye.”
Silence.
Michael frowned.
“What does it mean?”
Jessie didn’t know.
But Sophie did.
“Oh my God.”
Everyone turned.
Sophie stood beside the window.
“What?”
“My grandmother used to take Mom somewhere.”
Rachel frowned. “What are you talking about?”
“You told me once. When I was little. You said Grandma Catherine used to take you hiking near a river.”
Rachel stared.
“I barely remember.”
“You said there was a cedar tree that grew sideways over the water.”
Jessie’s pulse jumped.
Rachel closed her eyes.
Memory arrived.
“Blackbird River.”
Jessie stood.
“What?”
“That was what Mom called it. Not the real name.”
“Where?”
Rachel looked toward the north.
“Near the Quebec border.”
Jessie grabbed her coat.
Gabriel sighed.
“Of course you’re leaving immediately.”
“My supposedly dead mother may be alive.”
“She’d be what age now?”
Jessie calculated.
“Seventy-three.”
Anna looked at Rachel.
“If she’s alive, why hasn’t she contacted either of you?”
That stopped Jessie.
Good question.
Rachel looked at the cassette.
“Maybe she couldn’t.”
Michael spoke quietly.
“Or maybe she didn’t want to.”
Jessie looked at him.
That possibility hurt.
But it was possible.
Catherine might have built another life.
She might not want her daughters appearing after decades.
Choice.
Again.
Jessie slowly removed her coat.
Gabriel looked surprised.
“What?”
“We don’t storm in.”
“Who are you and what have you done with Jessie Wilson?”
She ignored him.
“We find the location first. Quietly. We verify what we can. Then we decide.”
Rachel watched her.
“You really are different.”
Jessie looked at her sister.
“I’ve spent eleven months trying.”
Rachel smiled faintly.
“I can tell.”
Rebecca had been examining Daniel’s cassette case.
“There’s something inside.”
She removed the paper label.
Behind it was a small folded note.
Daniel’s handwriting.
Jessie read it.
Catherine told me the greatest mistake Second Life ever made was believing secrecy alone could keep people safe. Secrets protect people until the wrong person owns them.
Below that: If Jessie reaches Catherine, tell her the truth before Catherine tells her version.
Jessie frowned.
“What truth?”
There was one final line.
Rachel read over her shoulder.
Her face changed.
“What?”
Jessie turned the paper.
Daniel had written: Catherine Wilson did not create Second Life to save people.
Jessie’s stomach dropped.
Underneath: She created it to find someone.
Nobody spoke.
Jessie stared at her mother’s name.
Everything they had just learned shifted again.
Catherine hadn’t begun with a rescue network, the rescue network had grown out of a search.
“For who?” Sophie whispered.
Jessie looked at Rachel.
Rachel didn’t know.
Michael didn’t know.
Anna didn’t know.
But Jessie suddenly remembered something else.
A childhood photograph.
Her mother kept it inside a kitchen drawer beneath dish towels.
Jessie had found it once.
Two little girls stood beside Catherine.
Rachel was one.
Jessie was the other.
Except now Jessie remembered there had been three children in the photograph.
She had always assumed the third was a cousin.
A boy.
Older than Rachel.
Catherine had snatched the photograph from Jessie’s hand when she found it.
“Who’s that?”
“Nobody.”
“Why is he with us?”
“Jessie.”
“Who is he?”
Catherine had looked frightened.
Jessie hadn’t understood it then.
Now she did.
Jessie looked at Rachel.
“We had a brother.”
Rachel’s face emptied.
“No.”
“Yes.”
“No, we didn’t.”
Jessie remembered his face.
Not his name.
A teenage boy holding baby Jessie while Catherine stood beside them.
Rachel shook her head.
“Mom never—”
“She erased him.”
Not medically.
From the family story.
Photographs hidden.
Name unspoken.
Existence removed.
Jessie suddenly understood why Catherine had built a network capable of finding people who had disappeared under new identities.
Second Life hadn’t originally been built to hide someone. It had been built to find someone who had already been hidden. Their brother.
Jessie’s phone buzzed and everyone jumped.
Unknown number. Jessie opened the message but there was no text. There was only a photograph.
A recent one of an elderly woman stood beside a river beneath a cedar tree bent almost horizontally over the water. She had grey hair and a red coat.
Jessie knew her immediately. It was Catherine. She was alive. Beside her stood a man in his late fifties.
Jessie stared at his face.
Rachel whispered, “Who is that?”
Jessie didn’t know but the resemblance was unmistakable. He had Rachel’s eyes, Jessie’s jaw and Catherine’s smile.
This was their brother.
A second message arrived.
You finally remembered him.
Jessie’s heart pounded.
Then another.
Now ask why he was taken.
Jessie typed with shaking hands.
Who is this?
The response came instantly.
Mom.
Rachel began crying.
Jessie stared at the word.
Twenty-four years of missing memory.
Twenty-nine years believing Catherine was dead.
An entire brother erased from their family.
Jessie typed:
Where are you?
Catherine didn’t answer the question.
Instead, another message appeared.
Do not come looking for me yet.
Jessie’s jaw tightened. Apparently stubbornness was hereditary.
Then: First, ask Michael what his mother did to your brother.
Every face turned toward Michael.
He looked horrified. “I don’t know.”
Jessie believed him.
Her phone buzzed one final time.
He does.
Then: He just doesn’t remember.
Jessie looked at Michael. Michael looked at Daniel’s cassette and suddenly the next part of the story wasn’t hidden inside Jessie’s missing year. It was hidden inside Michael’s.
Come back tomorrow for the next chapter
💜 Enjoying the chaos that is my life? Subscribe to The Cool Beans! It’s cheaper than therapy and slightly more organized 🤣
Leave a Reply