Hidden among the forests of southwestern New Brunswick is a lake with a name that sounds almost too peaceful for the stories attached to it. Lake Utopia, located in Charlotte County near the town of St. George, stretches for roughly seven kilometres through the landscape. People swim there, fish there, paddle across its waters and spend summers in cottages along its shores. But according to a legend stretching back well over a century, people may not be the only ones enjoying the lake.
Something else is said to live beneath the surface.
Locals have come to call it Old Ned, or simply the Lake Utopia Monster.
Stories of a strange creature in Lake Utopia appear to have circulated long before the monster became a newspaper curiosity. Later versions of the folklore attributed early accounts to Indigenous people in the region, including stories of hunters or canoeists encountering an enormous creature in the water. Because many of these early stories were recorded secondhand by later writers, however, it’s difficult to separate older oral tradition from details that accumulated as the legend was retold.
What we do know is that by the nineteenth century, people around Lake Utopia were taking the monster seriously enough to try to catch it.
In 1867, naturalist A. Leith Adams visited the area and discovered that residents had placed large baited hooks around the lake in hopes of capturing whatever they believed was living there. The excitement apparently followed reports of a strange disturbance in the normally calm water. Adams wasn’t convinced a monster was responsible and suggested natural explanations, including schools of fish or unusual disturbances caused by wind or underwater activity.
But the stories didn’t stop.
Reports from 1867 described sawmill workers witnessing something enormous thrashing through the lake. The creature was reportedly estimated at around 30 feet long, although eyewitness estimates involving mysterious animals should always be treated cautiously.
The following year brought another reported sighting, this time involving a journalist associated with the Saint Croix Courier. By the early 1870s, the creature had become enough of a local sensation that newspapers were publishing stories about attempts to find it.
Then an important figure entered the story.
William Francis Ganong was a respected New Brunswick naturalist, botanist and historian who became interested in reports of unusual creatures and phenomena throughout the province. In his notes from 1891, Ganong recorded the testimony of a local man named McCartney, who claimed he’d repeatedly encountered the Lake Utopia creature roughly twenty years earlier while working as a lumberman.
His description was striking.
According to the account Ganong recorded, the animal was dark reddish in colour, with approximately twenty feet of its body visible above the water. It was thick-bodied, possessed what appeared to be two large fins, and resembled an enormous eel. Interestingly, the witness said he never actually saw its head.
The lumberman also claimed he had seen the creature on multiple occasions.
Ganong nevertheless remained skeptical that an unknown monster was required to explain what people were seeing.
During his travels through New Brunswick, he’d noticed something that could transform an ordinary lake into surprisingly convincing monster territory: waterlogged trees.
Trees along lakes used for lumbering could die, fall into the water and become partially submerged. Waves could then roll the long, dark trunks through the water. Roots might briefly break the surface while other portions disappeared beneath it.
From a distance, especially in poor light, the effect could resemble a long animal swimming through the lake.
It was an explanation that required considerably fewer undiscovered prehistoric serpents.
But Old Ned wasn’t finished.
Decades passed, and reports continued to surface.
In 1969, a New Brunswick newspaper published the account of a woman who said she’d witnessed something enormous years earlier. She described what initially appeared to resemble a huge black rock, except this particular rock apparently had somewhere to be. It moved through the lake, disturbing the water and producing large waves.
Then came one of the better-known modern encounters.
In 1982, Sherman Hatt and members of his family reportedly saw something large rise from Lake Utopia. Hatt compared its appearance to a submarine emerging from the water, with spray coming from either side. He estimated that the exposed hump alone measured approximately ten feet.
Whatever he saw eventually disappeared beneath the surface.
Fourteen years later, Lake Utopia produced another particularly intriguing report.
In 1996, Roger and Lois Wilcox were canoeing when they noticed ripples breaking the otherwise calm surface roughly 100 metres away. Something appeared to be moving toward Cannonball Island, an area that has become closely associated with the monster legend.
Roger Wilcox reportedly estimated the creature at an extraordinary 40 to 50 feet long.
More interesting than the estimated size was the way he described its movement.
Rather than wriggling sideways like an eel or snake, Wilcox said the animal appeared to undulate vertically—moving upward and downward through the water. At one point, he reportedly saw a large hump rise several feet above the surface.
He considered several ordinary possibilities himself.
A porpoise?
An eel?
An otter?
Ultimately, he couldn’t identify what he’d seen.
And that’s where Old Ned remains today.
There is no body, DNA, bone, photograph or other physical evidence demonstrating that an unknown giant animal inhabits Lake Utopia. Eyewitness estimates of size can be unreliable, particularly on open water where there are few reference points. Swimming mammals, large fish, floating logs, wakes, waves and other ordinary phenomena can become remarkably strange when glimpsed unexpectedly from a distance.
There’s also an intriguing geographical detail. Lake Utopia isn’t completely isolated. Its waters are part of the Magaguadavic River system, which ultimately connects toward the Bay of Fundy. That connection has naturally inspired speculation that whatever people occasionally see might not necessarily spend its entire life inside the lake.
Still, speculation isn’t evidence.
Perhaps Old Ned was an unusually large known animal.
Perhaps witnesses saw different animals over the generations and those encounters gradually became attached to the same legend.
Perhaps Ganong was right and at least some of the monsters were nothing more exotic than waterlogged trees rolling through the waves.
Or perhaps something genuinely unusual occasionally moves beneath Lake Utopia.
Whatever the explanation, there is something wonderfully eerie about the fact that people were setting enormous baited hooks around this quiet New Brunswick lake more than 150 years ago, convinced that something extraordinary was swimming beneath them.
They never caught Old Ned.
And more than a century later, nobody has conclusively explained every reported encounter either.
Lake Utopia continues to look exactly like its name suggests – quiet, beautiful and peaceful.
But every now and then, according to the stories, the water moves.
And someone begins wondering whether Old Ned is still down there.
Sources: Bulletin of the Natural History Society of New Brunswick and the writings and notes of William Francis Ganong, MyNewBrunswick.ca’s “Lake Utopia Monster”, Backyard History’s “Old Ned, The Lake Utopia Sea Monster”, New Brunswick historical and archival materials concerning Lake Utopia and the 1872 Canadian Illustrated News depiction of the Lake Utopia Monster.
A little magic is always waiting. Subscribe and step inside the circle. 🖤🔮✨
The Cool Beans 
Leave a comment