Elara had been a witch for twenty-seven years before she finally accepted that she probably wasn’t getting a familiar. It wasn’t that every witch had one. Plenty didn’t. Familiars were not magical accessories handed out alongside cauldrons and suspiciously large collections of jars. They came when they came, if they came at all, and supposedly there was no shame in never finding one. Elara still felt cheated.
As a girl, she had imagined something magnificent arriving on her doorstep. Perhaps an enormous raven with silver eyes. Maybe a wolf that appeared mysteriously at the edge of the forest and immediately recognized her as its person. She would even have accepted an unusually intimidating owl. Instead, she got squirrels. Ordinary squirrels. They dug up her herbs, stole offerings from her garden altar, and once managed to hide seventeen walnuts inside a pair of winter boots she had left on the porch.
“You’re not mystical,” she informed one particularly fat squirrel one morning. The squirrel stared at her while eating a strawberry it had stolen. “You’re a criminal.” It continued eating.
Elara lived in a little cottage at the edge of a forest where the trees grew so closely together that sunlight arrived in scattered pieces. She spent her days drying herbs, making charms, tending her garden, and helping the occasional neighbour who appeared at her door asking whether she had anything for insomnia, heartbreak, bad luck, or husbands who refused to put their socks in the laundry basket. She usually did.
Her magic was quiet. Plants grew exceptionally well beneath her hands. Injured animals somehow found their way to her garden. Storms seemed to soften before reaching her cottage. When someone sat at her kitchen table crying, they often left feeling lighter without understanding why. Elara had eventually decided that perhaps quiet witches didn’t get familiars.
Then, one rainy October evening, something scratched at her door. Elara was stirring honey into tea when she heard it. Scratch. Scratch. Scratch. She froze. There it was again.
“Please don’t be another raccoon.”
The last raccoon had discovered where she stored dried apples and had subsequently behaved as though he’d inherited the cottage. Elara opened the door and looked left, then right, but there was nothing there. Then something sneezed.
Elara looked down. Sitting on her doorstep was the ugliest cat she had ever seen. He was soaked through. One ear was bent. His fur appeared to have once been black but was currently several interesting shades of mud. His tail had a permanent kink halfway down, and one enormous yellow eye stared at her while the other remained mostly closed.
“Oh,” Elara whispered. The cat sneezed again. “You look terrible.”
The cat walked inside.
“I didn’t invite you.”
He continued down the hallway, entered the kitchen, jumped onto one of her chairs, curled into a ball, and went to sleep. Apparently negotiations had concluded.
Elara named him Moth because he immediately developed an obsession with every candle in the house and possessed absolutely no survival instinct around open flames. He wasn’t magical. At least, Elara didn’t think he was. He knocked bottles off shelves, slept directly on whatever book she was trying to read, stole dried herbs from baskets and scattered them across the floor, and during rituals wandered directly through protective circles before occasionally sitting in the middle of them to wash himself.
“This is sacred work,” Elara told him one evening as he settled comfortably inside a circle she had spent twenty minutes preparing. “I need concentration.”
Moth lifted one leg into the air and continued bathing.
“Wonderful.”
Still, he stayed. Weeks became months. Moth followed Elara into the garden. He slept beside her while she dried herbs. When she gathered mushrooms in the forest, he trailed several feet behind, pretending they weren’t travelling together.
Something else began happening too. Her magic changed. Not dramatically, but it deepened. Plants whispered more clearly beneath her fingers. She sensed approaching storms days before clouds appeared. When she read cards, meanings came faster. Dreams became vivid and occasionally prophetic. Elara assumed she was simply becoming more experienced.
Until the night Moth disappeared.
She searched everywhere. She checked the garden, the shed, the road, and the forest. Hours passed, rain began falling, and by midnight Elara was walking through the woods carrying a lantern, soaked and terrified.
“Moth!”
Nothing answered.
Then she felt something. A tug, but not against her clothing. It was inside her chest. Elara stopped, and the sensation came again.
This way.
She turned from the path. Branches caught her sleeves as she pushed through the undergrowth, and the feeling grew stronger with every step until she reached an ancient oak that had been struck by lightning years before.
Moth sat beneath it, perfectly dry.
“Moth! You horrible little beast. I’ve been searching everywhere.”
He didn’t move.
Then Elara noticed what lay beside him. A young fox was trembling beneath the tree, one back leg caught beneath a fallen branch. Elara immediately knelt beside it.
“Oh.”
Moth touched his nose to her wrist, and something passed between them. Warmth. Recognition. Home. For one impossible second, she could feel him. Not his thoughts exactly, but something deeper. She felt his fear for the injured fox, his absolute certainty that Elara could help, and beneath everything else was a feeling so strong that tears suddenly filled her eyes.
He had chosen her.
Elara stared at him. “You… No. You cannot possibly be my familiar.”
Moth sat down.
“I waited twenty-seven years.”
He began washing his paw.
“I was expecting a raven. Possibly a wolf. Something majestic.”
Moth sneezed.
Elara started laughing. She laughed so hard she had to sit on the wet ground. All those years she had imagined her familiar arriving in a burst of moonlight and destiny. Instead, destiny had shown up muddy, half-starved, and looking like he’d lost several fights behind a tavern.
She carefully freed the fox, and Moth stayed beside her the entire time. Later, carrying the injured animal home wrapped inside her cloak, Elara felt that strange connection again. This time she didn’t resist it.
Images flickered through her mind. Roads. Barns. Forests. Cold nights. Different houses. Hands that had fed him. Doors that had closed. Miles and miles of wandering. Moth hadn’t simply appeared at her cottage. He had been travelling. Searching.
Elara stopped walking. “How long were you looking for me?”
Moth rubbed his head against her ankle. Her throat tightened as she picked him up. He immediately protested because apparently profound spiritual connections did not include being carried.
“I spent years wondering why you hadn’t come,” she whispered. “And you were trying to find me.”
He headbutted her chin.
Elara smiled. “Well, you took your sweet time.”
Moth purred.
From that night forward, Elara stopped wondering what a familiar was supposed to look like. Moth never became majestic. He continued knocking things off shelves, sleeping on spellbooks, and walking through carefully drawn circles at precisely the wrong moment. But whenever Elara worked magic, Moth was there—sometimes beside her, sometimes watching from the doorway, and sometimes snoring loudly enough to interfere with the atmosphere. And her magic was stronger for it.
Years later, a young witch visiting Elara’s cottage noticed Moth sleeping in a patch of sunlight.
“Is that your familiar?” she asked.
Elara smiled. “He is.”
The young witch studied the scarred ear, crooked tail, and round belly. “How did you know?”
Elara looked at the little creature who had crossed who knew how many roads before finally scratching at the right door.
“I didn’t.”
Moth opened one yellow eye, and Elara reached down to scratch beneath his chin.
“He knew.”
Perhaps that was the secret nobody had ever explained to her. You didn’t summon a true familiar, and you didn’t choose one because it looked mysterious enough, powerful enough, or magical enough. Sometimes two souls simply belonged beside each other, and somehow, through forests, storms, wrong turns, and years of searching, they eventually found their way home.
A little magic is always waiting. Subscribe and step inside the circle. 🖤🔮✨
Leave a comment