Michael did not speak for almost a minute. Jessie watched him carefully, knowing that silence was rarely empty. People filled it with decisions, calculations, fear, and sometimes lies, but Michael’s silence seemed to contain none of those things. It contained absence. He stood beside the long wooden table with both hands pressed against its edge, staring at Catherine’s final message on Jessie’s phone.
First, ask Michael what his mother did to your brother.
And then the second message.
He does. He just doesn’t remember.
Jessie understood the cruelty of those words better than anyone in the room. Michael had spent most of his life believing he was the one person Vale hadn’t successfully erased. He was the control, the one who remembered, the proof against Jessie, whose missing year had swallowed Daniel, Rachel, Sophie, and half the truth of St. Catherine’s. Now even that identity had been taken from him.
Rebecca stood beside him but didn’t touch him. Jessie noticed and respected it. Rebecca understood something many people didn’t: comfort wasn’t always contact. Finally, Michael looked at Jessie and admitted that he didn’t know her brother. When Jessie told him she believed him, he shook his head. “You shouldn’t. If Catherine says I knew him, then I probably did.”
“That’s not the same as remembering,” Jessie replied.
“It doesn’t change what I may have done.”
Jessie considered that before answering. “No, but we’re not convicting you based on a text message from my mother, who has apparently spent three decades pretending to be dead.” Rachel looked at her sharply, and Jessie shrugged. “I’m still adjusting.”
“So am I,” Rachel replied, lowering herself into a chair.
For the first time since arriving, Jessie really looked at her sister. Rachel had spent twenty-nine years believing Catherine was dead. Jessie had forgotten enough of their mother that the revelation felt almost abstract, but for Rachel, it was different. She had buried Catherine, mourned her, and raised Sophie without her. Now Catherine had sent a photograph from beside a river as casually as someone announcing she’d changed phone numbers.
Jessie glanced at the screen again. “She’s seventy-three.”
“And still dramatic,” Rachel muttered.
Jessie raised an eyebrow, and Rachel sighed. “That part you apparently inherited.”
“I am not dramatic.”
Gabriel made a small choking sound. Jessie turned toward him and asked whether he needed something. He quickly assured her he didn’t, while Anna studied the table and Sophie covered a smile. For three brief seconds, the room almost felt like a family gathering.
Then Michael asked them to play the rest of Daniel’s tape.
Rachel explained that there wasn’t much left, perhaps only a few minutes, but Michael insisted. Jessie studied his face and asked whether he was certain he wanted to hear it. He admitted he wasn’t, then straightened his shoulders and told Rachel to play it anyway.
Static filled the room before Daniel’s voice returned. “If Catherine is right, Michael won’t remember what happened to Jessie’s brother. He was never supposed to.”
Michael closed his eyes. Daniel sounded exhausted, and Jessie imagined him sitting alone somewhere in the original St. Catherine’s, injured and hunted, recording truths for people who might someday survive long enough to hear them.
“His name is Thomas Wilson.”
The name hit Jessie harder than she’d expected. Thomas was no longer an indistinct figure in a photograph, no longer a mysterious man standing beside their mother. He was her brother, and he had a name.
Rachel whispered it aloud, then pressed her fingers to her temple when Jessie asked whether she remembered him. At first, she shook her head, but something changed in her expression. “Tommy,” she murmured. “Mom used to say that name.”
Jessie asked when, and Rachel struggled to place the memory. Eventually she remembered their mother talking in her sleep, long before their father disappeared permanently from their lives. Jessie had always assumed Catherine’s grief belonged to him. Perhaps it hadn’t.
Daniel continued explaining that Thomas was Catherine’s first child, born when she was sixteen, shortly after she escaped the original institution. His father wasn’t Rachel and Jessie’s father, and Catherine had never revealed his identity to Daniel. Thomas had spent his earliest years inside Second Life, growing up while his teenage mother helped build a secret network for people escaping the same kind of institution that had nearly destroyed her.
“Catherine trusted the wrong person,” Daniel said. “That’s the first mistake I wrote about in the ledger.”
Jessie frowned. She had assumed Daniel’s reference to a first mistake concerned something he had done himself. Anna quietly observed that he had apparently been talking about Catherine instead.
Daniel explained that Catherine had allowed someone inside Second Life access to Thomas because she believed survivors wouldn’t deliberately hurt one another. Jessie thought about how easily trust could become a weapon in the wrong hands. When Thomas was nine years old, he disappeared.
Rachel covered her mouth, but Jessie was already remembering something. She saw a kitchen, their mother screaming into a telephone, and Rachel leading her upstairs while Catherine sank to the floor. Jessie had been very young, perhaps four, and for decades she had forgotten the reason for her mother’s distress. Now a single sentence returned with devastating clarity.
“They took him,” Jessie whispered. “Mom said, ‘They took him.’”
Rachel began crying because she remembered it too.
Daniel explained that Catherine spent years searching for Thomas. Every survivor she helped provided another connection, another city, another institution, or another name. Eventually, helping people became Second Life’s larger purpose, but Catherine never stopped searching for her son. Jessie thought about Daniel’s warning that Catherine hadn’t originally created Second Life to save people. She had created it to find someone.
When Thomas was fourteen, Catherine finally found him at the original St. Catherine’s institution, the very place she had escaped. Eleanor had not personally taken Thomas, but she had known where he was for five years and had said nothing.
Rebecca asked why, and Daniel’s recording supplied the answer. Eleanor believed Thomas was safer there.
Jessie closed her eyes. Protection through control. It was the same justification that had followed them through every revelation. Catherine had searched desperately for her son while her closest friend withheld the truth, convinced she knew what was best for him.
Catherine tried to bring Thomas home, but he refused. He had been told his mother abandoned him and that Eleanor had rescued him from a dangerous woman. At fourteen, he believed the people who had kept him captive. Catherine found her son and still couldn’t bring him home.
Three years later, Thomas disappeared again. Eleanor claimed she didn’t know where he had gone, but Daniel revealed that she had handed him over to Vale.
Anna quietly suggested that Thomas must have been Vale’s first candidate, but Daniel corrected that assumption. Vale had not called Thomas a candidate. He had called him Prototype.
Jessie felt her skin crawl. The language was unmistakable. Thomas hadn’t been treated as a person but as an experimental starting point. Eleanor had convinced herself that Vale could undo the psychological damage caused by the original institution. Instead, he used Thomas to develop the methods he would later inflict on Michael, Anna, Jessie, and the others.
Vale promised to restore Thomas’s attachment to Catherine, turning a mother’s desperate wish to reconnect with her son into the foundation of his research. Jessie realized that Vale’s obsession with loyalty and attachment hadn’t begun with her relationship with Daniel. It had begun with Catherine and Thomas.
Thomas escaped Vale when he was nineteen and eventually found Catherine again. Rachel couldn’t understand why he hadn’t returned to their family, but Daniel explained that he had. For one night, when Rachel was fourteen and Jessie was nine, Thomas had come home.
Jessie remembered a young man sitting at their kitchen table. He had dark hair, a bruised face, and a tired smile. Catherine was crying while Rachel watched from the hallway, and Jessie stood barefoot on the stairs. The man looked up at her, opened his arms, and called her “little bug.”
The memory struck so suddenly that Jessie caught her breath. She remembered running downstairs and hugging him, not because she knew who he was, but because something about him felt safe.
Thomas had left before morning, believing Vale would find him and hurt Catherine’s daughters if he stayed. Jessie remembered an argument in the kitchen, fragments of voices, and a door closing. She couldn’t remember who had said what, but she understood the choice. Thomas had disappeared to protect them, just as Jessie would later disappear from Sophie’s life.
Families repeating the same desperate mistakes without realizing it.
Daniel explained that Thomas spent the following years trying to expose Vale. That was how Daniel met him, and Thomas had taught Daniel much of what he knew about the program before Daniel ever met Jessie. Daniel had promised Thomas he wouldn’t reveal their relationship unless Thomas agreed.
Jessie didn’t know whether to feel furious or heartbroken. Daniel had loved her, but he had also believed that protecting someone meant deciding which truths they were allowed to carry. She was beginning to understand how much damage even well-intentioned secrecy could cause.
Then Daniel’s recording turned to Michael.
Eleanor had brought Michael to St. Catherine’s when he was eleven. She told Daniel’s mother that the boy had been abandoned, concealing the fact that Michael was her own biological son. Thomas recognized Michael and understood his connection to Eleanor. For six weeks, he worked to gain the boy’s trust and find a way to help him escape.
Michael began trembling as fragments of memory returned. He remembered a man bringing him food and warning him not to drink the orange juice because medication had been added to it. He remembered a scar near the man’s temple, the same scar visible in Catherine’s recent photograph of Thomas.
Then he remembered Eleanor arriving and telling him the man was dangerous. She claimed Thomas intended to kidnap him and take him to Catherine, whom she described as the leader of a criminal trafficking network. Michael, only eleven years old and desperate to trust his mother, believed her.
He told Vale that Thomas was planning an escape.
Daniel’s recording fell silent for several seconds before his voice returned, quieter than before. He explained that Michael had been a frightened child manipulated by adults who knew exactly how to exploit his need for safety. Eleanor had told Michael he’d saved everyone, and Vale had subsequently altered parts of his memory.
Michael had always believed he was the control, the one subject whose memories remained intact. That belief was another lie.
Vale had left fragments behind, and those fragments had become nightmares. Michael admitted that he had dreamed of the same room since he was eleven. In the dream, a man called his name from behind a locked door, and Michael walked away.
“Every time, I walk away,” he said, his voice breaking.
Jessie crouched in front of him and reminded him that dreams weren’t confessions. She understood how convincing a false memory could become, particularly when it carried guilt. She had spent twenty-four years believing she understood Daniel’s death, only to discover that almost every detail had been manipulated.
Michael insisted he must still bear some responsibility, and Jessie didn’t dismiss his feelings. She simply reminded him that an eleven-year-old child deceived by his mother and a powerful adult was not responsible in the same way as the people who engineered the situation.
Then Daniel revealed something neither of them expected.
Thomas had survived, and Michael hadn’t abandoned him.
Vale had made Michael remember walking away because he wanted guilt attached to obedience. In reality, Michael had returned, stolen a red key, unlocked the room, and told Thomas to run.
Michael stared at his hands as the memory returned. He remembered the key, the door, and the terrified man on the other side. He remembered telling Thomas to hurry.
“You saved him,” Daniel said from the recording.
Michael collapsed into his chair, sobbing. Rebecca held him while Jessie looked away, understanding that some truths weren’t hers to watch.
Vale had done more than steal memories. He had altered Michael’s understanding of his own morality, removing evidence of kindness while preserving guilt. He had made Michael believe he was someone who abandoned people when, in the moment that mattered, he had gone back.
Daniel’s final words to Michael were simple. “If you remember nothing else, remember this. You went back.”
Jessie’s eyes filled. Daniel had said the same thing about her. Perhaps that was why he had loved them both, not because they were flawless or incapable of hurting anyone, but because they were people who sometimes found the courage to return.
When the tape ended, the room remained quiet. Michael sat beside Rebecca for several minutes before looking at Jessie and saying that they needed to find Thomas. Jessie agreed, although Catherine had stopped answering messages.
Jessie sent three texts. In the first, she told Catherine that Michael remembered. In the second, she explained that he remembered helping Thomas escape. Neither received a response. When Jessie finally wrote that they knew about the blackbird, the phone rang immediately.
Jessie answered cautiously. “Mom?”
For several seconds there was only breathing. Then an elderly woman’s voice greeted her.
“Hello, little bug.”
Jessie felt the years collapse. She remembered Catherine using the same nickname when she was ill, carrying her upstairs and settling her into bed. Rachel began crying beside her, and Jessie could barely speak.
Rachel took the phone long enough to confront their mother. Catherine admitted she was alive, admitted she had allowed Rachel to believe she was dead, and acknowledged that she had missed Sophie’s childhood. When Rachel warned her not to excuse everything by claiming she had been protecting them, Catherine surprised everyone by agreeing.
Jessie took the phone back and demanded to know where Thomas was. Catherine insisted he was safe, but when Jessie asked to speak to him, her mother said she needed to know who was listening first.
Jessie immediately suspected surveillance. Gabriel moved toward the curtains, but Catherine warned him not to bother. She claimed she knew Gabriel’s habits well enough to predict that he would check the windows when frightened.
Gabriel went pale when Catherine revealed that they had met years earlier. He denied remembering her, but she described a blue Buick with a broken passenger-side mirror and a photograph of Rebecca inside the glove compartment. Gabriel sat down when Catherine told him he had once driven her across the border.
He couldn’t remember it.
Jessie immediately suspected Vale, but Catherine admitted she had helped Gabriel bury the memory herself, at his request. According to Catherine, Gabriel had seen Thomas that night and learned something that could have endangered Rebecca if Vale discovered he knew it.
Jessie demanded an explanation, but Catherine refused to discuss it over the phone. When Jessie pressed her about whether she and Thomas were in danger, Catherine admitted they were. She also revealed that Vale was no longer the immediate threat. Eleanor remained alive, although Catherine claimed she didn’t know where she was.
Michael was visibly shaken to learn his biological mother might still be alive. Catherine addressed him directly, but she offered no answers about Eleanor’s whereabouts.
Instead, she warned them that the people behind the original St. Catherine’s knew Vale had been arrested. They wanted the records Thomas had gathered, and they were particularly interested in Rebecca because she had uncovered the foundation’s financial network.
Catherine explained that Second Life and the organization behind Vale had become entangled years earlier. Some branches still provided genuine help to vulnerable people, while others collected information and identified potential subjects. Many employees had no idea what the larger organization was doing.
Jessie realized the problem was far more complicated than finding a single villain. A system could contain people doing meaningful work while others used the same resources for terrible purposes.
Catherine also believed someone close to Jessie had been feeding information to the organization since Nathan stole her file. Michael immediately suspected Evan, who had worked for Vale for six years, but Jessie wasn’t prepared to settle on the easiest answer.
Then Catherine asked whether Jessie still had the group photograph from locker 316.
Jessie retrieved it. The photograph showed Daniel, Rachel, Sophie, Laura, Michael, Anna, Evan, Gabriel, and a young woman everyone had assumed was Jessie. Catherine asked her to consider who had taken the picture.
Jessie was confused. She was in the photograph, so she couldn’t have been the photographer. Catherine told her to look more closely at the young woman standing beside Daniel.
Jessie studied the clothing, hair, and posture. Something felt wrong. When she enlarged the photograph, she noticed the absence of the tiny scar cutting through her left eyebrow, a scar she had received at sixteen.
The woman looked remarkably like Jessie, but she wasn’t Jessie.
Catherine identified her as Candidate Eight.
Jessie protested that Evan had been Candidate Eight, but Catherine explained that Vale had changed the records after the woman disappeared. Her name was Julia, and she had been trained to resemble Jessie.
Rebecca immediately recognized the implications. Vale hadn’t simply studied whether emotional attachments survived memory disruption. He had experimented with identity substitution, training one person to imitate another through appearance, behaviour, mannerisms, and voice.
Julia had been fifteen when Vale began transforming her into Jessie’s replacement. Cosmetic procedures, physical conditioning, and years of psychological manipulation had been used to make her resemble someone else.
Jessie felt sick. Julia had been a child whose identity was deliberately dismantled.
When Jessie asked whom Julia was supposed to replace her for, Catherine answered that Vale had intended to kill Jessie during the St. Catherine’s fire and then use Julia to test whether Daniel’s attachment could be transferred to someone conditioned to behave like her.
The cruelty of it was almost impossible to comprehend. Daniel’s grief would have become another experiment.
Catherine explained that Julia had disappeared after the fire, although she had recently been seen near Thomas. When Jessie asked whether Julia hated her, Catherine admitted that she did. Vale had spent years telling Julia that she existed only because Jessie did.
Jessie understood how destructive that would be. Julia’s entire life had been shaped around becoming another person, only for that person to survive. Yet Catherine revealed something unexpected: Julia had saved Jessie’s life during the fire.
Vale’s people had been watching the exits, and Julia had put on Jessie’s jacket to draw their attention away from her. Suddenly, Jessie remembered the photograph left in her apartment at the beginning of the investigation, the image of a young woman beside Daniel with his face scratched away.
Everyone had assumed it showed Jessie.
It showed Julia.
Daniel had been trying to save her too.
Jessie looked at the old photograph with new understanding. Julia was not simply another possible threat. She was someone Vale had exploited, someone who had risked her life to save Jessie, and someone whose story had been buried alongside the others.
Catherine admitted that Thomas and Julia had been working together for twenty-three years, beginning shortly after Daniel’s death. They had been trying to identify the people behind St. Catherine’s and expose the organization that had survived Vale.
Recently, they had discovered who was running the foundation’s dangerous operations. They went to verify the information and disappeared.
Jessie was furious that Catherine hadn’t revealed this immediately. Rachel was angrier still. She confronted their mother for continuing to decide what other people were emotionally prepared to know, pointing out that the same habit had destroyed their family for decades.
Catherine finally acknowledged that she had been confusing protection with permission. Jessie demanded that the secrecy end. No more riddles, hidden trails, or carefully rationed information.
To everyone’s surprise, Catherine gave them the address of her cabin near a river in Quebec.
She explained that Thomas had contacted her after Vale resurfaced, hoping to finish the work he and Julia had begun. Thomas had divided his evidence into three parts. Catherine possessed one, Thomas had kept another, and Daniel had received the third.
But Daniel’s portion was missing.
Catherine revealed that Daniel had entrusted it to Gabriel, who had transported a red suitcase across the border. Gabriel slowly remembered carrying it to a train station, where he met a dark-haired woman with a little girl.
Rachel recognized the details. She had been that woman, and she had received the suitcase from Gabriel after the fire. She had intended to deliver it to Daniel, but someone else arrived first.
A woman who looked like Jessie.
Julia.
Rachel had given Julia the suitcase because she knew the code phrase Daniel had arranged. That suggested either Daniel trusted Julia or Julia had learned the phrase another way.
Catherine confirmed that Thomas and Julia had been working together ever since Daniel died. For more than two decades, they had searched for the people responsible for St. Catherine’s, while Jessie and the others had unknowingly been following pieces of the same investigation.
Jessie was beginning to understand how thoroughly secrecy had divided them. Daniel, Catherine, Thomas, Julia, Rebecca, Evan, Michael, Nathan, and Jessie had all pursued answers through separate channels, often believing they were alone.
When Jessie announced she was going to Quebec, the others began preparing to join her. The detective warned that nobody would be conducting an unsupervised investigation across provincial lines, which Jessie interpreted as his volunteering to help.
Rachel initially refused to let Sophie accompany them, then caught herself. She explained that she was frightened for her daughter’s safety rather than pretending Sophie had no right to decide. Sophie listened and maintained that she wanted to come.
Rachel reluctantly agreed.
Michael and Rebecca also insisted on going, while Gabriel tried unsuccessfully to discourage his daughter. Anna announced that she had waited twenty-four years to learn who had ruined her twenties and wasn’t about to stay behind. She added that she could always buy cinnamon buns along the way.
For the first time, Jessie felt they were making choices together rather than following instructions planted by Vale, Evan, or anyone else.
Then her phone rang.
Evan sounded frightened. He told Jessie he had found Nathan Carter, but when Jessie reminded him that Nathan was in the hospital, Evan revealed that the hospitalized man wasn’t Nathan at all.
The real Nathan was with Evan, injured but alive.
When Jessie spoke to him, Nathan apologized for starting the entire chain of events. He explained that he hadn’t stolen Jessie’s file from Vale. He had obtained it from the foundation, where he had worked as a transport driver for fourteen years.
The person who hired him was a woman whose real name he didn’t know. Nathan described someone in her early forties, with dark hair, Jessie’s build, and a scar through her left eyebrow.
Julia.
Apparently, Julia had eventually added the one identifying feature she had lacked in the old photograph.
Nathan explained that Julia had instructed him to find Jessie if anything happened to her. She believed Jessie was the only person who could finish Second Life, although Nathan quickly clarified that she didn’t mean Jessie should take control of it.
Julia wanted Jessie to destroy it.
Jessie looked around the room at the table carved with the names of people Second Life had helped. The network had begun as a mother’s search for her missing son, evolved into a rescue organization, been corrupted by Vale, and later rebuilt by Daniel. Some of its branches still saved people, while others used the same infrastructure to identify vulnerable individuals.
Perhaps Daniel had been wrong about one thing. Maybe Second Life was no longer a promise that could be protected by maintaining the institution. Maybe the promise existed independently of the organization.
Nathan revealed that the foundation was preparing a new initiative called Continuity, intended to carry on Vale’s work. When Jessie asked how many people were involved, Nathan admitted he had seen thirty-two files.
They weren’t candidates or Mercers. They were children.
The room went cold. Nathan explained that the children hadn’t been taken yet, but Julia and Thomas had been trying to stop the operation before it began. Thomas knew where the files were kept.
Nathan then gave Jessie the address where Julia and Thomas had gone the previous day.
Rebecca entered it into her phone and stopped. The location wasn’t in Quebec. It was in Ontario, in a city Jessie knew intimately.
Hamilton.
After decades of hidden institutions, burned churches, false identities, and secrets stretching across provinces, the next answer had apparently been sitting in the same city where Jessie had tried to build an ordinary life.
The foundation owned a youth outreach centre there. It was active, and the public had no reason to suspect its connection to the larger organization.
Jessie felt a cold anger settle over her. The location wasn’t a fortress or an underground laboratory. It was somewhere families might turn for help, a place built to inspire trust.
Nathan said Julia and Thomas had gone there the previous day, but he didn’t know whether they had come out. Someone had attacked him before he could investigate further, and that person was now apparently pretending to be Nathan in the hospital.
Jessie immediately recognized the pattern. Identity substitution. Vale’s oldest obsession had survived him.
She alerted the detective, who began arranging for the hospitalized impostor to be secured and identified. Then Jessie’s phone received a message from Nathan’s number, even though the real Nathan was still speaking to her through Evan’s phone.
The message contained a photograph of Emily Carter sitting at a kitchen table. Beside her was Mrs. Alvarez, Jessie’s elderly neighbour, who was holding a piece of banana bread. Neither appeared restrained, although Jessie had no way of knowing what was happening outside the frame.
The accompanying message complained that Jessie’s people were difficult to control. A second message explained that Mrs. Alvarez had bitten someone.
Jessie laughed despite herself. She showed Gabriel, who looked equally bewildered, and even Michael managed a small smile.
Then another message arrived, ordering Jessie to come to Hamilton and bring the ledger.
Jessie’s amusement disappeared.
For days, everyone had wanted her to follow instructions. Vale, Evan, Michael, Catherine, and now another unknown person had attempted to direct her movements by controlling what she knew or threatening someone she cared about.
Old Jessie would have obeyed because she believed she alone could control the outcome. She would have gone quietly, carrying the ledger and trusting her ability to improvise.
Instead, she typed a single refusal.
The reply threatened that people would get hurt.
Jessie handed the phone to the detective and asked him to trace it. She instructed Michael to secure the ledger and asked Rachel to contact Catherine with the new information about Hamilton.
Gabriel watched her retrieve her coat and asked what she intended to do.
“Something I’ve apparently spent my entire life being terrible at,” Jessie replied. “Trusting other people to help.”
She looked around the room at Gabriel, Anna, Rachel, Sophie, Michael, Rebecca, and the detective. Nathan was still on the phone, with Evan somewhere beside him. These were people who had lied to her, people she had lied to, people who had hurt one another, and people who had saved one another. Sometimes they were the same people.
For the first time, Jessie understood what Daniel had meant about Second Life.
It wasn’t the ledger, the foundation, the money, the identities, the safe houses, or the network. All of those things could be corrupted, stolen, or turned against the very people they were meant to protect.
The promise was simpler. If any of them survived, none of them would have to survive alone.
Jessie zipped her coat and announced that they were going home. Gabriel pointed out that Hamilton wasn’t home for most of them, but Jessie looked at him and smiled faintly.
“It is for me.”
And for the first time since this began, Jessie wasn’t returning to the past.
The past had come looking for her.
Come back tomorrow for more….
💜 Enjoying the chaos that is my life? Subscribe to The Cool Beans! It’s cheaper than therapy and slightly more organized 🤣
Leave a Reply